0 items in Cart
  • Home
The Magpie Bakery Logo
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

The Magpie Bakery Online Ordering Menu

2 14 RIVERSIDE SQUARE
BLOOMINGDALE, NJ 07403
(973) 291-6756
7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
97% of 39 customers recommended
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability
Menu Icon Legend

Cakes & Cupcakes

Searching for good cake? Enhance your celebration with a delicious cake or cupcakes from The Magpie Bakery!
Pre-Order Cakes 
We can make your vision come to life! See our social pages on IG and FB for some of our beautiful cake creations. In addition we have gluten free Red Velvet or Carrot Cake available for pre-order.
$0.00+
Cupcake Chocolate 
$3.50
Cupcake Vanilla 
$3.50
Cupcake Red Velvet 
$3.75
Vegan Chocolate Cupcake 
$3.75
Cupcake (Special Design or Color) 
$3.75
Cheesecake 4" Small 
$15.00
Cheesecake 6" Medium 
$23.00
Cheesecake 8" Large 
$35.00

Mini Desserts

Create a beautiful dessert platter with our delicious mini desserts! Order individually or by the dozen.
Mini Maple Pecan Bread Pudding 
$2.00
Mini Brownie Bite 
Rich fudgy brownie bites with a kiss of chocolate frosting.
$2.00
Mini Cannoli Tart 
Mini graham cracker cup filled with cannoli cream sprinkled with chocolate chips.
$2.00
Mini Keylime Tarts 
Made with real key limes, get ready to pucker up for this tart!
$2.00
Mini Lemon Curd 
Tart lemon curd in a pastry cup.
$2.00
Mini Smores Cup 
$2.00
Mini Devils Food Cake 
$2.25
Mini Vanilla Cupcake 
$2.25
Mini Chocolate Cupcake 
A delicious fudgy chocolate cupcake with real chocolate buttercream. Can be modified for vegan option.
$2.25
Mini Classic Cheesecake W/ Graham Crumb 
$2.25
Mini Classic Cheesecake W/ Oreo Crumb 
Rich creamy chocolate cheesecake over Oreo crumb, a perfect bite size.
$2.25
Mini Gluten Free Banana Nutella Muffin 
A simultaneous flavor explosion of Banana and Nutella in one bite, so good!
$2.25
Mini Crumb Cake 
$2.00
Mini Coconut Tart 
$2.00
Mini Chocolate Pecan Tart 
Made with real maple syrup, toasted pecans and a chocolate drizzle in a mini pastry cup.
$2.25
Mini Vegan Cupcake 
$2.50

Breakfast Pastries

One bite of our buttery, flaky pastries and it will feel like you're on vacation!
Apple Turnover 
$3.50
Plain Croissant  
$4.25
Chocolate Croissant  
$4.25
Almond Turnover 
$4.25
Cinnmon Rolls 
$3.75
Cherry Yogurt Danish 
$4.25
Lobster Tail 
$3.50
Sfogliatelle 
$3.50
Tomato Olive Pastry 
$4.25
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Stuffed Croissant 
$5.50
Egg & Cheese Stuffed Croissant 
$5.50
Melty Ham & Cheese Croissant 
$5.50
Spinach Pastry 
$4.25

Bakery Items

See our variety of delicious artisan baked goods.
Brownie - Chocolate Chip 
$3.50
Brownie - Walnut 
$3.50
Crumb Cake Classic 
$3.25
Crumb Cake Apple Butter 
$3.50
Crumb Cake Rasperry 
$3.50
Crumb Cake Strawberry 
$3.50
Crumb Cake Blueberry 
$3.50
Muffin Blueberry 
$3.75
Muffin Chocolate Chip 
$3.75
Muffin Double Chocolate Chip 
$3.75
Muffin Coconut Lemon Raspberry 
$3.75
Muffin Chunky Monkey 
$3.75
Muffin (VG) Morning Glory 
$4.25
Muffin (GF) Banana Nutella 
$4.25
Muffin (GF) Raspberry Chia 
$4.25
Mixed Berry Bread Pudding 
$3.50
Sticky Maple Pecan Bread Pudding 
$3.50
Scone Blueberry 
$3.50
Scone Chocolate Chip 
$3.50
Scone Orange Cranberry 
$3.50
Scone Triple Berry 
$3.50
Scone Broken/small Discount 
$3.00
Scone Savory - Maple Sausage 
$3.75
Scone Savory - Vegetarian 
$3.25
Oatmeal Whoopi Cookie 
$3.75
Chocolate Chip Whoopi Cookie 
$3.75
Cute Sugar Cookie 
$1.25
Chocolate Chip Cookies 
$2.50
Lintzer Tart Cookies 
$1.50
Cannoli 
$3.50
Savory Scone Tray 8x8 
$25.00

Beverages

Did you know we make excellent espresso drinks, chai and maccha? We also brew our own signature iced teas, Lavender Vanilla and Mango Passionfruit, perfect for a hot summer day.
Hot Coffee 
$2.65+
Hot Cappuccino 
Equal parts espresso, steamed milk and foamed milk. Usually served straight up without any flavoring, but the foam is often sprinkled with powdered chocolate or cinnamon.
$3.95+
Latte 
a coffee drink of Italian origin made with espresso and steamed milk.
$4.45+
Hot Mocha 
café mocha is based on espresso and hot milk but with added chocolate flavouring and sweetener, typically in the form of cocoa powder and sugar. Whip cream is optional.
$4.25+
Hot Chocolate  
$3.25+
Hot Chai 
Hot Chai is a tea beverage made by boiling black tea in milk and water with a mixture of aromatic herbs and spices.
$2.95+
Hot Matcha 
$3.95+
Espresso 
a strong, concentrated coffee made by forcing pressurized water through finely ground coffee beans. Served in a small cup called a demitasse, and meant to be taken quickly, like a shot.
$3.75
Cortado 
A cortado is a beverage consisting of espresso mixed with a roughly equal amount of warm milk to reduce the acidity. The milk in a cortado is steamed, but not frothy and "texturized" as in many Italian coffee drinks.
$3.75+
Macchiato 
sometimes called espresso macchiato, is an espresso coffee drink with a small amount of milk, usually foamed. In Italian, macchiato means "stained" or "spotted" so the literal translation of caffè macchiato is "stained” or “marked coffee.”
$3.75+
Hot Tea 
$2.95+
Hot Americano 
$3.25+
All Iced Drinks 
$3.75+
The Magpie Iced Tea 
$3.75+
The Abby® 
$5.00+
Box of Joe 
$22.00

Sweet Pies
Classic Cherry Pie Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$5.95
Classic Cherry Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Classic Cherry Pie Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Peach Raspberry Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$5.95
Peach Raspberry Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Peach Raspberry Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Apple Blueberry Pie Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$5.95
Apple Blueberry Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Apple Blueberry Pie Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Strawberry Rhubarb Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$5.95
Strawberry Rhubarb Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Strawberry Rhubarb Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Apple Crumb Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Apple Crumb Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Lemon Meringue Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Lemon Meringue Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Key Lime Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Key Lime Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$36.50+
Cream Pie Coconut Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Cream Pie Coconut Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Cream Pie Chocolate Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Cream Pie Chocolate Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Cream Pie Banana Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Chocolate Maple Pecan Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Chocolate Maple Pecan Pie Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$32.00
Triple Berry Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Blueberry Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00

Savory Pies
Chicken Pot Pie Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
Chicken Pot Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Chicken Pot Pie Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$38.00
French Onion Soup Pie Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
French Onion Soup Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Shepard's Pie Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
Shepard's Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Shepard's Pie Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$38.00
Curried Potato and Lentil Hand Pie Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
Curried Potato and Lentil Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Pulled Pork Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
Pulled Pork Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Mac & Cheese Pie Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
Mac & Cheese Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Mac & Cheese Pie Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$36.00
Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Roasted Butternut Squash Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
Roasted Butternut Squash Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Steak & Ale Hand Pie (Single Serving) 
$7.95
Steak & Ale Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings) 
$16.00
Steak & Ale Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings) 
$38.00
Quiche Lorraine - Medium, 2-3 servings. 
$14.00
Quiche Lorraine - Large 7-8 servings. 
$24.00
Broccoli & Cheddar Quiche - Medium 2-3 servings. 
$14.00
Broccoli & Cheddar Quiche - Large 7-8 servings. 
$24.00
Spinach & Tomato Quiche, Medium 2-3 servings. 
$14.00
Spinach & Tomato Quiche, Large 7-8 servings. 
$24.00

Slice Of Magpie
Slice of Magpie Cherry Pie Slice 
$4.50
Slice of Magpie Peach Rasperry Pie Slice 
$4.50
Slice of Magpie Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Slice 
$4.50
Carrot Cake Slice 
$4.50
Carrot cake Wedge 
$3.99
Cheescake Wedge 
$3.99
Slice of Magpie Mac & Cheese Pie Slice 
$4.50

Trays/Platters
Scone Vegetarian Scone Tray 4"X6" 
$12.00
Scone Maple Sausage Scone Tray 4"x6" 
$14.00
Crumbcake Tray 8x8 - Fruit Flavor 
$22.00
Crumb Cake Tray 8x8- Classic 
$20.00
Cookies Magpie Cookie Platter (3 Whoopie, 3 Choc Chip, 3 Lintzer And 3 Cute Sugar Cookies. ) 
$22.00
Cookies Sugar Cookie Pack (6 Cute Sugar Cookies) 
$6.00
Choco Chip Cookie Pack (6 Cookies) 
$12.00
Snickerdoodle Cookie Pack (6 Cookies) 
$12.00
Pumpkin Cookie with Maple Glaze Pack (6 VG Cookies) 
$12.00
Brownie's Tray - Choco Chip 4"X6" 
$9.95
Brownie's Tray - Walnut 4"X6" 
$9.95

Artisan Breads And Rolls

We recommend pre-ordering bread, so we have it fresh out of the oven!
Olive Loaf 
A beautiful unsliced oval loaf, with a hearty crust, with olives in bite.
$8.00
Raisin Walnut Loaf 
A rustic unsliced oval loaf, aromatic with sweet raisins and a crunch of walnut in every bite.
$8.00
Baguette 
Classic French Baguette
$3.50
Bread Roll (Single) 
A hearty farmhouse roll. Great for sandwiches, BBQ or a simple breakfast.
$1.75
Country French Boule 
A round, unsliced French Country Loaf.
$5.50
Your cart is empty.
  • Visit our Facebook Visit our Instagram
Powered by Menufy © 2022
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.